50 Impossibly Hard Would You Rather Questions

Think you're good at Would You Rather? These questions have no good answers. Both options are equally appealing - or equally terrible. Good luck.

The Hardest Choices

1. Would you rather know when everyone you love will die, or know when you will die?
2. Would you rather be able to save 100 strangers, or 1 person you love?
3. Would you rather have everyone forget you exist, or remember you but hate you?
4. Would you rather experience the happiest moment of your life knowing it will never be that good again, or never experience it at all?
5. Would you rather always know the truth (even when it hurts), or believe comfortable lies?

Success vs. Happiness

1. Would you rather be wildly successful but deeply unhappy, or unsuccessful but content?
2. Would you rather achieve everything you want alone, or achieve nothing but surrounded by love?
3. Would you rather be the best at something no one cares about, or mediocre at something everyone values?
4. Would you rather have the perfect career or the perfect relationship?
5. Would you rather be remembered for something you regret, or forgotten entirely?

Time Paradoxes

1. Would you rather relive your best day forever, or never experience it but have variety?
2. Would you rather go back 10 years with everything you know now, or skip forward 10 years?
3. Would you rather live 1000 years in the past or 1000 years in the future?
4. Would you rather age backwards from 80, or age normally from 0?
5. Would you rather have one year left to live and know it, or 50 years but never know when it ends?

Moral Dilemmas

1. Would you rather steal to feed your family, or let them go hungry?
2. Would you rather lie to protect someone's feelings, or tell the truth and hurt them?
3. Would you rather break a promise to help a stranger, or keep a promise and let them suffer?
4. Would you rather do one terrible thing for a great outcome, or many small good things that don't add up?
5. Would you rather forgive someone who isn't sorry, or hold a grudge that poisons you?

Identity Questions

1. Would you rather know exactly who you are but never change, or constantly evolve but never feel settled?
2. Would you rather be yourself and disliked, or be someone else and loved?
3. Would you rather have others see you as you truly are, or as you wish to be?
4. Would you rather know your purpose but be unable to fulfill it, or fulfill your purpose without knowing what it is?
5. Would you rather change one thing about your past, or guarantee one thing about your future?

Why Hard Questions Matter

Easy questions are fun. Hard questions are transformative.

When there's no good answer, we're forced to examine our values at the deepest level. The discomfort of choosing reveals what we truly prioritize.

These conversations stay with you. Days later, you might still be thinking "but what if I had chosen the other one?"

That's the point.

Play Deep Questions →